Content marketing forgot the audience was supposed to join in.

Around 2010 the marketing world discovered content. Inbound, editorial calendars, brands as publishers. The pitch was a good one: stop renting attention with ads and earn it instead, by making things people actually want.

I was working in-house at an Australian internet provider then, and I bought the pitch completely. I wrote the strategy decks. I’ve just reread them, along with the award entry for a campaign we ran in the middle of it all. Some of it has aged well and some of it hasn’t, and the difference is worth a look.

A competition, not a content hub

In late 2010 we launched a national talent search for the country’s biggest technology enthusiast.

The reason was simple. The company had been built by internet enthusiasts telling their less technical friends and family who to sign up with. The company was now big and advertising nationally, and we didn’t want to lose those people. So we made something for them, with a message attached: being capable and passionate about something is worth celebrating.

Anyone could enter or nominate a friend. You made a profile and posted photos, videos and links to prove your particular kind of obsession. The public voted. Judges picked finalists, who then faced four challenges: pitch an invention on video, write the premise for a TV show or film, play off in games stores around the country, and sit a live quiz at the final. The prize was a trip for two to one of the big fan and technology conventions overseas.

1. Enter→ 2. Shortlist→ 3. Challenges→ 4. Final Entrant 1312 votes+ vote Entrant 21,204 votes+ vote Entrant 32,877 votes+ vote Entrant 4946 votes+ vote Entrant 51,630 votes+ vote
How it ran, redrawn. The entrants, faces and vote counts here are made up.

Over four months:

  • Hundreds of people entered.
  • Tens of thousands of votes came in from the public.
  • Tens of thousands of people visited the competition site.
  • Entrants made close to a hundred original videos, watched tens of thousands of times, plus a couple of hundred blog posts and a podcast a fan started on their own.
  • On the night of the final, the hashtag was the top trend on Twitter in Australia.

We wrote very little of that. To get votes, entrants campaigned on their own blogs, Twitter accounts, Flickr pages and podcasts, and then started talking to each other. The newspapers, radio and TV followed because there were real people with real stories in every state.

The campaign had no sales target. A few hundred sales were still traced back to people who’d come across it on the way to buying.

What made it different

Look at what most brands now call content: an article about the brand’s own subject, in the brand’s own voice, on the brand’s own site, or the same thing paid into a publisher’s feed and labelled native. It’s finished before anyone sees it. The audience’s only job is to read it.

The competition was unfinished on purpose. We built the stage, the rules and the prize, and the content was whatever people did with them. It was a moment with a start, a middle and a final, and you could be in it.

That’s the difference between publishing at people and giving them something to take part in.

Publishing at people Brand writes it→Audience reads it→ The end. Something to take part in Brand buildsthe stage→People makethe content→Friends voteand share→More peoplejoin in
The first is finished before anyone sees it. The second isn’t finished until people turn up.

The plans I wrote at the time

Two documents from those years make an honest test.

The 2010 strategy. I argued that we and our competitors were all fighting over the same few search terms and cancelling each other out, while comparison sites delivered customers who’d leave for the next cheap deal. The alternative was to open the company up: publish what our staff knew, answer the long tail of real questions, and let customers contribute, with a community doing much of the work. One line from it still holds: people turn to the internet for information first and product second. The shift I wanted was from paid media towards earned.

The 2014 workshop. By then the language had settled. The brand becomes the publisher. Content runs always on while campaigns come in bursts. Purpose over promotion. And for anything paid into someone else’s publication, one condition: the audience must find value in it.

The audit, fifteen years on

What became common practice: nearly all of it. In the Content Marketing Institute’s latest annual survey, 97 per cent of B2B marketers say they have a content strategy. Always-on publishing is normal. Every brand has a blog, a help centre and a channel. On that score, the decks won.

What lived up to its promise: answering real questions. Publishing what you know, in the words people search with, worked for years and built real businesses. It was the least glamorous part of the plan and the most dependable.

What went flat: almost everything else. Three numbers tell it.

  1. Fewer than three in ten B2B marketers rate their content strategy as very effective, according to the Content Marketing Institute’s 2025 research. Most say “moderately”.
  2. When Ahrefs looked at about 14 billion pages, it estimated that 96.55 per cent get no traffic from Google at all.
  3. In a sample of 900,000 newly published pages in 2025, Ahrefs found about three quarters contained AI-generated text.
Under 3 in 10B2B marketers who ratetheir content strategyas very effective 96.55%of pages studied getno traffic fromGoogle at all 3 in 4newly published pagesthat containAI-written text
Sources: Content Marketing Institute (2025), Ahrefs (2023), Ahrefs (2025).

So the industry took an idea about earning attention and turned it into a volume game. More articles, each a little more like the last, most of them read by nobody. It’s the same thing that happened to digital advertising after 2009: the part you could count and scale pushed out the part that made an impression.

And now the volume game is being taken away. Pew Research tracked what people do when Google shows an AI summary at the top of the results. They clicked through to a website about half as often as when there was no summary, and clicked a link inside the summary about one time in a hundred. If your content exists to answer a common question, a machine is increasingly answering it for you, without the visit.

Where I was wrong. My 2010 plan had two halves: fill the long tail with answers, and build a community that takes part. I gave the first half most of the pages. That’s the half everyone did, and the half that’s now a commodity. The second half is the one that produced the competition, and it’s the one that almost nobody carried on with, including us. We meant to run it again the next year.

The opportunity that’s still there

A machine can write the thousandth article about how to set up a home network. It can’t hold a final, pick a winner or make hundreds of people ring their friends for votes.

Here’s what I’d take from all this now.

  1. Make fewer things, and make some of them events. One thing a year that people can enter, vote on, turn up to or argue about will do more than fifty articles.
  2. Start with your most fervent customers. Every business has a small group who care more than is reasonable. Build for them first and let them carry it out to everyone else.
  3. Publish what only you know. Your own data, your staff’s experience, your opinion. That’s the content that can’t be generated, and it’s what the AI answers have to cite.
  4. Leave it unfinished. Decide what the audience adds: an entry, a vote, a photo, an answer. If the honest answer is “nothing”, you’ve made an ad. That’s fine, but make it a good one.
  5. Measure the conversation as well as the traffic. Entries, votes, mentions, people searching for you by name. Our competition would have looked like a failure in a report that only counted visits to product pages.

Content marketing wasn’t a bad idea. It was a good idea that got turned into a production line. The part worth going back for is the part where the audience joins in.

Sound familiar?

Tell me what’s going on. I’ll reply with questions or a scoped proposal.