Find the stage where your marketing falls short.

Feel, See, Think, Do: a benchmark of your marketing against competitors, stage by stage.

Usually a fixed project, kept up afterwards within ongoing management if you want.

Most marketing reviews look at one channel at a time. This one looks at the whole path a customer takes, in four stages: how they feel about the brand, whether they see the product, what they find when they think it over, and whether they do anything about it.

For each stage I measure your share against your competitors’. The test is simple. Your share of each stage should at least match your share of the market. Where it falls well short, there is a gap holding back everything after it. Where it runs well ahead, you may be paying too much for that stage.

This is for you if

  • Growth has stalled and no single channel explains why.
  • Most of the budget goes to the last click and returns are flattening.
  • You need to make the case for brand or organic investment in numbers.
  • You want one view of the whole funnel, compared with competitors.

Feel

Brand. Broad, emotional advertising that makes people well disposed towards you before they need you. Measured by brand tracking, share of brand media spend, share of brand searches and homepage visits.

See

Product. More targeted advertising that makes sure people know what you sell. Measured by product tracking, share of product media spend, share of product searches and product page visits.

Think

Owned and earned. Being found by people who are looking and comparing. Measured by share of non-brand organic search traffic, content page traffic and enquiry or sign-up start rates.

Do

Converting. Turning intent into a sale through paid search, remarketing and offers. Measured by share of non-brand paid search, share of remarketing and sales conversion rates.

Do is where most digital budgets pile up, because last-click reporting gives it the credit. Spending there without the first three stages drains the pool of interested people and returns fall away.

How the work runs.

  1. Set

    Agree the competitors and your rough share of the market, which becomes the line every stage is judged against.

  2. Gather

    Your own analytics, ad and sales data, plus search trends, traffic estimates and media spend estimates for each competitor.

  3. Index

    Your share of each measure, stage by stage, set beside your market share.

  4. Diagnose

    Which stages are short, which are over-fed, and what each gap is likely costing.

  5. Plan

    Where to move budget and effort first, with the sums behind it.

Deliverables

What you end up with

  • A Feel, See, Think, Do scorecard against your competitors
  • Your share of each stage beside your market share
  • The largest gaps, sized in traffic or sales terms
  • A recommended shift in budget and effort
  • Sources and method for every figure
  • A findings session with your team

Where AI comes in

It gathers the inputs, not the verdict

I use AI to collect and tidy the inputs: search trend exports, traffic estimates and competitor media activity. The benchmark arithmetic is checked by hand, and the reading of what each gap means is mine.

How I use AI

Fair things to ask.

Something else? Ask me directly.

What does a gap look like in practice?

For one large national utilities provider, brand and product search share was about 8% and paid media and paid search share about 13%, but share of non-brand organic search traffic was 1%. That stage was eight to thirteen times smaller than the business’s size suggested, which made organic search the obvious first investment.

Is this the same as a brand identity or design review?

No. It doesn’t judge your logo or tone of voice. It measures how your marketing performs at each stage of the customer’s path, compared with competitors.

How is it different from a competitor audit?

A competitor audit compares you channel by channel. This arranges the same kind of evidence into four stages and tests each against your market share, so it shows where the whole system is out of balance.

How reliable are the competitor figures?

Your own numbers are measured. Competitor traffic and spend are estimates, so I use them as shares and ratios, where they are dependable, and say so beside each one.

Do we need brand tracking research?

It helps if you have it. If you don’t, search trends and direct traffic stand in for it well enough to show the shape.

Something driving you mad?

Tell me what’s going on. I’ll come back with questions or a scoped proposal, and I’ll say so if I’m not the right person for it.