A media plan with ten logos on it looks thorough. Social, video, two display networks, native, a mobile network, a couple of news sites. The reasoning is sound enough: people’s attention is scattered, so be in more of the places they are.
The result is often a campaign that reaches a great many people once or twice each, and changes nobody’s mind.
The arithmetic nobody draws
Say you’re aiming at a quarter of a million people, and you’ve decided the message needs to be seen about eight times to land.
The budget is split across ten platforms. Each one can afford to show the ad to its share of the audience about twice. The hope is that those twos stack up: the same person sees it twice here, twice there, twice somewhere else, and you arrive at eight.
They mostly don’t stack. Each platform finds its own people, by its own method, from a pool far bigger than your target. One reaches this slice, the next reaches a different slice. Draw it as ten bars and the shaded part sits at a different height in every one.
So you don’t get a quarter of a million people at eight times. You get something closer to a million people at twice. Reach has gone far beyond what you planned, and frequency has fallen to a level where most messages don’t register.
Why the platforms can’t fix it for you
No platform knows what another platform showed. Each reports its own reach and its own frequency, and each report looks healthy on its own. Nothing in any dashboard adds them up into one person’s experience.
Devices make it worse. A phone is recognised one way and a laptop browser another, so the same person can be counted as two people and capped as two people. The more the plan relies on cookies and device identifiers, the further the reported frequency drifts from the real one.
It gets worse again when the plan carries several messages. A frequency that’s too low for one message is hopeless for three.
Stack on one audience first
The way round it is to resist adding channels and start with platforms that can reach one defined audience in several ways.
Define the audience once on a platform that spans more than one product and format, and the same people can see a video, then a native post, then a story, then an image ad. Those exposures do stack, because the platform knows it’s the same person. Four placements at twice each really is eight.
It’s the same budget and the same audience size, with a much better chance of the frequency you planned.
When to add a channel
More channels aren’t wrong. They’re the second step. I’d add one when:
- The first platform is full. You’re reaching nearly all of the target at the frequency you want, and more spend there only repeats itself.
- It reaches people the first can’t. That means a clearly different audience, and it needs a budget big enough to reach them properly.
- It does a different job. Search catches people who are looking. That’s a different task from building familiarity, and it should be planned and measured separately.
A new line on the plan that does none of those is thinning out what you already have.
What I’d do
Write down the audience size and the frequency you’re aiming for before choosing any channel. Work out what that costs on one platform that can reach those people across formats. Fund that properly first.
Then look at what’s left. If it isn’t enough to reach a worthwhile audience often enough somewhere else, don’t spend it somewhere else. Extend the campaign you’ve got, or keep it running longer.
A plan with three logos on it is harder to present than one with ten, and it’s usually the one that works.