One ad can’t do four jobs.

Open most ad accounts and you’ll find one idea doing all the work. The same image and the same line are shown to people who have never heard of the business, to people comparing it with two others, and to people who put something in the cart yesterday. Then the whole lot is judged on cost per sale.

Those are different people who need different things, and one ad can’t give all of them what they need. The plan I use splits the work into four stages. It borrows from the well-known See, Think, Do model and adds a stage in front of it.

Feel Whole market one to many See Target market one to some Think In the market one to few Do People you can name one to one
The audience gets smaller at each stage and the message can get more specific. Heights are illustrative, not measured.

Feel: the whole market

This is everyone who could ever buy, most of whom aren’t looking today. The job is for them to like the brand, so that it’s already familiar when the need turns up.

  • Targeting: one to many. Broad, on purpose.
  • Timing: big campaigns, a few times a year, seen only a handful of times each.
  • Channels: video, audio, outdoor, press.
  • Judge it on: brand awareness and how often people search for you by name.

I call the spend here positive waste. Most of the people who see it won’t buy this year, and that’s the point. You are paying to be remembered later. Judge this stage on sales this month and you’ll cut it, then wonder a year on why everything further down costs more.

See: your target market

Now the audience narrows to the kinds of people who actually buy. They know the category. The job is to move them from “I’ve heard of them” to “I’d consider them”, usually by correcting an assumption: it’s more affordable than you thought, simpler than you thought, closer than you thought.

  • Targeting: one to some, by interest and context.
  • Timing: mid-sized campaigns in the periods that matter, seen often enough to register.
  • Channels: targeted video and audio, digital outdoor, high-impact display and social.
  • Judge it on: awareness of the campaign and the product, and searches for the product.

Think: people in the market now

These people are actively looking. They’re searching, reading reviews and comparing. The job is to be found and to give them something useful to do: a tool, a guide, a quote.

  • Targeting: one to few, using signs that someone is in the market.
  • Timing: always on.
  • Channels: paid and organic search, social prospecting, reviews, native.
  • Judge it on: your share of the traffic in your category, and how many people start and finish an enquiry or quote.

Do: people you can name

The last stage is people who have already been to the site, started a quote or bought before. The job is to finish what they started, or to bring them back.

  • Targeting: one to one.
  • Timing: always on.
  • Channels: remarketing, email, text message, a phone call.
  • Judge it on: conversions and conversion rate.

Where it usually goes wrong

Everything is measured like the last stage. Cost per sale suits Do. Applied to Feel, it makes brand spend look like a failure, so the budget drifts to remarketing, which takes the credit for sales the earlier stages set up.

The creative doesn’t change. Lay your current ads out under the four headings. If you can’t tell which column an ad belongs in, neither can the person seeing it. Often three of the four columns are the same ad with a different button.

A stage is missing. Plenty of businesses run Do and a bit of Think and nothing else. It works until the pool of people already looking runs dry, and then costs climb with no obvious cause.

The frequency is wrong for the job. A brand film seen twice is fine. An in-market message seen twice is invisible. Each stage needs its own answer to “how many times”.

What I’d do

Draw the four columns on one page. Under each, write who it’s for, what you want them to think afterwards, where it runs, how often, and the one number you’ll judge it by. Then sort the ads you already have into the columns and look at the gaps.

Most plans turn out to have plenty in the last column and very little in the first two. Fixing that balance usually does more than any amount of tuning inside the campaigns you already run.

Sound familiar?

Tell me what’s going on. I’ll reply with questions or a scoped proposal.